Chapter 3:
Ilyin’s Post-Soviet Hagiographs
The perestroika years, which opened with Mikhail Gorbachev becoming General Secretary in 1985, radically changed the context in which memory of the émigré movement could be expressed. The process of reinstating anti-Bolshevik figures within Soviet culture took place fitfully prior to 1985; afterwards it exploded. An outpouring of information on Russian émigrés and their views occurred in parallel with Gorbachev’s decision to open the archives and authorize the rewriting of some chapters of twentieth-century history. This resulted in radical change to the Soviet historical narrative and paved the way for the impressively quick reemergence of an émigré version of history.

Epitomizing that trend, in 1990 the Paris-based émigré publisher YMCA-Press, close to NTS, was allowed to organize an exhibition of émigré books at the Moscow Library of Foreign Literature, giving unheard-of access to previously prohibited émigré figures and narratives.1 Leonid Reshetnikov (1947), a senior Foreign Intelligence Service official connected to the Russian Party, published in 1990 the first-ever biographical article on the émigré thinker Ivan Solonevich (1891–1953), known for his argument that monarchy was the only viable and historically justified political system for Russia. But it was Ivan Ilyin who attracted the most interest in this new Russia thirsty for non-conformist views.
Nikita Mikhalkov. Source: Wiki Commons
Film director Nikita Mikhalkov claims the paternity of the rediscovery of Ilyin. A member of the family that led the Russian Party during the Soviet era and intimately connected with émigré culture,2 Mikhalkov has been the engine of the cultural rediscovery of the White past through its cinematographic production. In 1991, his small publishing house Trite released a brochure by Ilyin, which he presented to Aleksandr Rutskoi, then vice-president of Russia.3 After the reading, Rutskoi began
quoting Ilyin regularly, especially in his political manifesto, “Political Credo of a Vice-President,”4, and was followed by Communist Party leader Gennadi Ziuganov. The fashion for Ilyin in conservative, or, as they were called in Russia, “red brown patriot” circles was launched.

Another central political figure of Ilyin’s rehabilitation at that time was Boris Mironov (1951), cofounder of Rossiiskaia gazeta, then president of the Media Committee of the Russian Federation. Known for his nationalist and antisemitic views, Mironov led the Soviet Russia publishing house, which republished Ivan Ilyin, as well as 19th century conservative thinker Konstantin Pobedonostsev, Russian philosopher Konstantin Leontiev, and Vasily Shulgin, one of the central figures of Russia’s White emigration.5 Mironov would later co-lead the extremist, National Great-Power Party of Russia (NDPR) along with Alexander Sevastyanov and Sergei Terekhov.
Boris Nikolaevich Lyubimov. Source: Wiki Commons
In more intellectual circles, Ilyin’s first early popularizer outside conservative and nationalist circles was the theater critic Boris Nikolaevich Lyubimov (1947). It was he who, for the first time in the Soviet Union, published fragments of Ilyin’s works outside of the samizdat world: these appeared in the journal Teatral’naia zhizn’ (Theatrical Life) in 1989.5 Lyubimov, who is now the rector of the Higher Theater School named after M. C. Shchepkin, is also a member of the Board of Nikita Mikhalkov’s Fund for Russian Culture (see below). The Lyubimov and Mikhalkov families have been friends for years; some unconfirmed rumors suggest that Mikhalkov is the godfather of Lyubimov’s daughter, Olga Borisovna Lyubimova, who has been serving as Minister of Culture of the Russian Federation since January 2020.6 Olga Lyubimova has been publicly critical of her years at an Orthodox collegium and presents herself as liberal Orthodox.7 She has produced several films on Orthodox culture and worked for years in the Movies Department of the Ministry of Culture, allowing her to maintain a relationship with Mikhalkov.

After Lyubimov’s republication of Ilyin in 1989, the rehabilitation became massive. Several articles devoted to his political philosophy were published by 1991; a ten-volume collection of his works was printed by 1993. These were followed by several conferences and a documentary film.

This rapid rehabilitation was made possible by the merging of émigré supporters of the philosopher with ideological figures in search of a new political language. This merging is embodied by the figure of Yuri Lisitsa (1947).
Yuri Lisitsa. Source: VK.com
Yuri Lisitsa was born in the Vinnitsa region of Ukraine and graduated from Patrice Lumumba Peoples' Friendship University (now Peoples' Friendship University of Russia) with a degree in Mathematics.8 Having achieved his Doctor of Physical and Mathematical Sciences, he began studying forbidden religious philosophy in 1965 as part of the Pan-Russian Artistic and Scientific Restoration Center (Vserossiiskii khudozhestvenno-nauchnyi restavratsionnyi tsentr, VKhNRTs), a club around the Church of the Resurrection of Christ in Kadashi, one of the central neighborhoods of Moscow.9

The Club was led by Pavel Korin, a leading restorator who was fascinated by icons and painted nostalgic landscapes of traditional Russia. Korin would later become one of the founders of the Russian Society for the Protection of History and Culture (VOOPIIK), an institution central to the attempt to fuse Soviet ideology and Russian nationalism and which would become the cradle of the future Pamiat, the school for Russian nationalist cadres.10

In the Kadashi circle, one could also find Vladimir Vorobiev (1941). Vorobiev’s father, Nikolai V. Vorobiev, was one of Ilyin’s students at Moscow State University . Vladimir was raised in a religious atmosphere and, after a first degree in mathematics and physics, decided in the 1970s to study at the Moscow Spiritual Academy to become a priest. During the perestroika years and the early 1990s, he was very active in Orthodox associative life. In 1992, he became the first rector of the newly created Orthodox St. Tikhon Humanities University—where Lisitsa would later teach.11

Since then, Vorobiev has been one of the main engines behind the Russian Orthodox Church’s (ROC) lobbying efforts to penetrate state institutions. He has worked, for instance, in the Coordination Council between the ROC and the Ministry of Education to get religious institutions accredited. He has also been an active member of the Synodal Commission for canonization.12 The Commission launched the ROC’s central memory policy of New Martyrs and Confessors (novomucheniki i ispovedniki), i.e., clerics persecuted for their faith by the Soviet repressions and whom the ROC had canonized.13 The canonization of the New Martyrs and Confessors was a prerequisite for ROC reunification with ROCOR, which has glorified them since the early 1980s.

It is possible Lisitsa met in the same religious circle Sergei S. Khoruzhii (1941–2020), a fellow mathematician and specialist in hesychasm who would become one of the main names of contemporary Russian philosophy. Lisitsa discovered Ilyin in 1985 through Khoruzhii, who first gave him the second volume of Our Missions, which contains Ilyin’s more moderate texts, before giving him the first volume, Ilyin’s more politically engaged pamphlets.14

Lisitsa also met in this religious circle Viktor N. Trostnikov (1928–2017), a student of Khoruzhii and an apologetic of Ilyin, who would have a huge influence on Lisitsa. Likewise a mathematician by training, Trostnikov defended a PhD in philosophy and began publishing in dissident circles. One of his books, Thoughts before Dawn (Mysli pered rassvetom), was published in Paris in 1980, which caused him to lose his academic position in the Soviet Union. In 1983 he began participating in the restoration of the Danilov monastery, found a technician job there, and then moved in 1986 to the Sergiev Possad monastery to work as chief fireman. In 1988, the ROC invited Trosnikov and priest Dmitri Dudko (the latter could not make the trip) to travel to the US to attend a celebration of a millennium since the baptism of the Rus’ organized by ROCOR. We do not have information on whom he met there, but he mentioned support from the ROCOR Holy Trinity Monastery in Jordanville, New York, and during a second trip in 1990 established contact with ROCOR New York Metropolitan Vitalii (Ustinov).15

The celebration of Russia’s Christianization was a turning point in the state- church relationship: originally intended to be purely a Church affair, the celebration was transformed into a national event when Mikhail Gorbachev gave it state backing. In 1992, Trostnikov began working for the St Ioann Bogoslov Russian Orthodox University and became a professor of philosophy there.16

In 1990, taking advantage of the perestroika context, which was favorable for rediscovering émigré culture, the professor Aleksandr L. Dobrokhotov (1950)17 invited Nikolai Poltoratsky to the MGU Philosophy Department for a series of conferences. The latter died of a heart attack soon after his lectures in Moscow — but his legacy would be a long-lasting one. Indeed, at that conference, Poltoratsky met the whole circle of Russia-based Ilyin disciples: Lisitsa, Khoruzhii, and a young Aleksandr Iu. Kazakov (1965), who would later serve as a Latvian representative of Dmitri Rogozin’s Congress of Russian Communities.18 The Congress of Russian Communities was the first organization to develop a political program based on Solzhenitsyn’s vision for Russia and to articulate the idea of Russians as a “divided nation” across the new post-Soviet borders that needed to be reunified.19 Kazakov would go on to supervise several pro-presidential youth movements, become the director of the Center for liberal- conservative politics named after Petr Stolypin and Petr Struve, and serve as a member of the public council of the ROC Department for Church-Society Interaction.20
At the 1990 conference, Dobrokhotov also proposed creating an Ivan Ilyin Society and publishing his complete works.21 The idea of an Ilyin Society did not come to fruition, but the publication of Ilyin’s complete works would become Lisitsa’s life work. Indeed, after the conference, Lisitsa began publishing on Ilyin in different journals and tried—unsuccessfully— to get himself elected to Mossovet (Moscow municipality government) on a program based on Ilyin’s ideas.

In 1992, Khoruzhii was invited to teach at Middlebury College in the US. There he met Irina Georgievna Ben-Chavchavadze, as well as her cousin, Alexei Evgenievich Klimov (1901–1991), who had cherished Ilyin’s legacy during the whole emigration period. The Klimov’s often hosted the Ilyins at their dacha in Koknese. Irina and Alexei were in correspondence with Ilyin and had very warm personal relations.22 Alexei had emigrated to Canada after the Second World War, and went to study with Poltoratsky at Michigan on the recommendation of his uncle Konstantin Klimov, an old friend of the Ilyins back from their time in Latvia in the interwar period.23 Khoruzhii told Klimov and Ben-Chavchavadze that Lisitsa, as the best specialist on Ilyin in Russia, should be the one charged with the republication of the philosopher’s work in his motherland. Upon his return to Moscow, Khoruzhii handed over to Yuri Lisitsa a package from Klimov and Ben-Chavchavadze containing photographs and materials related to Ilyin.24

Lisitsa gradually emerged as the leading one of Ilyin’s rehabilitators.25 From 1993 to 1996 the publisher Russkaia kniga began publishing Ilyin’s work under Lisitsa’s leadership, with the support of a RGNF (Russian Humanities National Foundation) grant. Between 1998 and 2000, he benefitted from another grant from the RGNF—and possibly from other sources of funding—to edit the correspondence between Ilyin and Ivan Shmelev (1873–1950), an émigré writer famous for his idyllic recreations of the prerevolutionary past and a supporter of the collaborationist Vlasov army. This project allowed Lisitsa to access about 200 kg of Ilyin’s writings sent from the US by Klimov.26 Klimov also introduced him to Tamara Poltoratskaya, who was then 85, and made Lisitsa Ilyin’s executor attorney.

After Ilyin’s reburial (see below), Lisitsa continued to promote Ilyin to higher political circles. In 2008, for instance, to mark the 125th anniversary of Ilyin’s birth, he edited a volume on
Ilyin’s Teaching on Russia’s Law, Power, and Social Culture (Uchenie I.A. Il’ina o prave, vlasti i sotsial’noi kul’ture Rossii) validated by the Committee for Constitutional Legislation of the Council of the Federation27— led at that time by Alexander Torshin. Torshin, a member of Dugin’s Eurasianist International Movement, now under the protection of Konstantin Malofeev, has become known for his role in the Russian interference in the 2016 elections and the Maria Butina case. Lisitsa is said to have been in touch, through Pavel V. Florensky (a professor at the Gubkin State University of Oil and Gas and grandson of the émigré philosopher Pavel Florensky), with senior hierarchs of the Church such as Tikhon and even Patriarch Alexii II.28

Since 2005, Lisitsa has been Head of the Department of Religious Studies at the Orthodox St. Tikhon Humanities University.29 The project of publishing Ilyin’s complete works is now led by St. Tikhon University, with the support of its rector, Lisitsa’s old friend Vladimir Vorobiev. In 2015, the project gained the official support of then-Minister of Culture Vladimir Medinsky, accompanied by funding from the ministry (see below). Promoting Ilyin’s thinking has become a family project: Lisitsa’s spouse, Olga Vladimirovna, has been transcribing Ilyin’s correspondence and works as program manager of the Russian Cultural Foundation, while their son Andrei has also helped with the republication of Ilyin’s works.


Made on
Tilda